Below is a re-post of a blog post I wrote with Fragrance
Fighters. The information is still so relevant today. Please read...
Fragrance Free or Unscented? Natural or Organic? Not All Are Equal! May 16, 2008 by
fragrancefighters
My four year old came to me looking for a
toy doll bottle with what she says has yellow cow’s milk. As I looked
into her bright eyes (I felt like a deer in headlights), I told her
that I had
no idea what is she talking about. She looked at me, rolled her eyes and said “Mommy, let me explain it to you”; and she did.
On our Savvy FAQs page we addressed two questions:
1. What is the difference between fragrance free and unscented?
2. Should I purchase only organic and products labeled natural?
Well let me explain something to you and let’s go a step further.
Products labeled no fragrance or fragrance free usually are free from
synthetic or chemical fragrance. The label does not purport that the
product is odorless.
Let me give you an example. Although I often use a popular brand of
baby products, on March 31, 2008 I spoke about a hypersensitive day that
I was experiencing. I was unable to use either their Super Sensitive
Shampoo and Bodywash or the Everyday Lotion because of the
odor
I detected. According to the label, this product does not have sodium
lauryl sulfate, formaldehyde, fragrance, scent masking agents or clear
formula chemicals, yet I detected an odor. The product has aloe vera,
extracts of corn, coconut and palm. Whatever the source, there is a
detectable smell or odor which on that day annoyed me. The odor or smell
was a source of irritation to Nancie and my husband (who do not share
our sensitivities) as well. For those with sensitive noses, you have to
smell the product to find your level of sensitivity and tolerance.
Unscented products usually add a masking agent, another chemical, to
disguise the chemicals in the product. Even though the masking agents
mask the scent they can trigger allergic reactions in chemically
sensitive people.
In
my quest to find natural or organic products with no odor, I find many
of these products tend to use essential oils although they do not use
synthetic fragrance. Essential oils are concentrated oils extracted
from herbs, plants or fruit. These oils have the distinct scent that
comes from the plant from which they are derived. For some, essential
oils are aromatherapy. For people like me it can trigger headaches,
migraines, nausea and the like. For Nancie it can trigger the same or
even worse; vomiting or an Asthma attack.
To complicate matters even further, on March 14, 2008 the Organic Consumers Association released the following to the press:
Carcinogenic Found in Leading “Organic” Brand Personal Care Products. .
1,4-Dioxane is a petroleum based carcinogen known to cause cancer and
is also suspected as a kidney, central nervous system and respiratory
toxicant. In the Organic Consumers Association Press Release, the OCA
urges consumers to search ingredient lists for indications of
ethoxylation including: “myreth,” “oleth,” “laureth,” “ceteareth,” any
other “eth,” “PEG,” “polyethylene,” “polyethylene glycol,”
“polyoxyethylene,” or “oxynol,” in ingredient names.
Even though a product is labeled natural or organic doesn’t mean it is
safe. The products may have natural or organic in the name but unless
it is labeled Certified Organic USDA it probably isn’t.
Where does that leave us? Frankly, I don’t know. I keep trying to
remind myself that “Balance is the Key” but the challenge is great. All I
want is safe non-odorous products that don’t make me sick. Is that too
much to ask? Well, explain it to me.
Remember the toy bottle my daughter was looking for with the yellow
cow’s milk? Well, I threw it out. It was on the U.S. Consumer Product
Safety Commission recall list for hazardous toys.
